Crest Ridge Construction Group, Inc. v. Newcourt Inc.

BENAVIDES, Circuit Judge,

specially concurring:

Because I agree that the evidence is sufficient to support the jury’s verdict that a contract existed and that Neweourt breached it, I concur in the judgment. I write separately because I reach the same conclusion as the majority, but by a different path — one I believe is consistent with the general principles of contract law and the Uniform Commercial Code.

The majority accurately recaps the factual background of this dispute. Neweourt initially issued a price quote to J.B. & Associates. This was followed by an “add-on” price quote to Crest…