Union Texas Petroleum, a Division of Allied Chemical Corp. v. Corporation Commission

BARNES, Vice Chief Justice,

dissenting.

Upon rehearing in this cause and upon reconsideration of the opinion promulgated herein on July 21, 1981 (52 OBJ (Vol. 52-No. 30) 1857), I hereby change my vote from “concur” and must respectfully “dissent”.

My first departure from the Majority’s conclusion pertains to the standard of review to be used in this case.

Article IX, Section 20, Oklahoma Constitution, makes two provisions relative to the duty and power of this Court in considering appeals from orders of the Corporation Commission. In appeals from orders of the Corporation Commission, “the review…