Legal Opinion · Dissent

Matter of Ferrill

New Mexico Court of Appeals

Decided June 23, 1981No. 4898Published

1DissentWalters, Judge

I do not agree with the majority opinion in the following particulars:

1. There is a distinction between the court having discretion to order a trial by jury if the parties have failed to make a timely demand when the issues are those covered by New Mexico Rule 38, and when the court may order a trial by an advisory jury, or a jury trial by consent of both parties (Rule 39(b) as opposed to Rule 39(b)). There is no constitutional nor common law right to trial by jury in probate matters, see Sheley v. Shafer, 35 N.M. 358, 370, 298 P. 942 (1931); State v. Ninth Judicial District, 40 N.M. 331,…

2Cases cited5 opinions

  1. State v. BazanNew Mexico Court of Appeals · 1977
  2. In re the Estate of FrankNew York Surrogate's Court · 1937
  3. Sheley v. ShaferNew Mexico Supreme Court · 1931
  4. State Ex Rel. Gallegos v. District Court, Ninth Judicial Dist.New Mexico Supreme Court · 1936
  5. Frock v. FowlieNew Mexico Supreme Court · 1969

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API