Salmon v. Arents

Hooker, J. (dissenting):

This is an appeal by the defendant individually and as administratrix of the estate of her deceased husband, Charles R. Arents, from a judgment of foreclosure of a chattel mortgage'in favor of plaintiffs, copartners. The mortgage was duly executed by tlie deceased and filed in the proper office oirthe 12tli day of July., 1-901. A renewal .statement was also filed in the proper'office on or about tliq 10th day of July, 1902. The mortgagor died on the 2d day of August, 1902; and there is ho proof or finding that arenewal statement or a copy of the chattel mortgage was…