Legal Opinion · Dissent

Whiteley v. Ingham Circuit Judge

Michigan Supreme Court

Decided January 23, 1900Published

Mandamus by James Whiteley and others'to compel Eollin H. Person, circuit judge of Ingham county, to allow relators certain costs in an action of ejectment.

1DissentGrant, J.

Eelators were defendants in an ejectment suit tried in the circuit court, appealed to this court, and affirmed. Whiteley v. Whiteley, 110 Mich. 556. Eelators were granted a new trial under section 10981, 3 Comp. Laws 1897. Before trial was had, plaintiff submitted to a voluntary nonsuit, which was consented to by the relators. Eelators now seek to recover costs of the first trial, in which the judgment was affirmed in this court. But for the statute, relators’ right to further litigation would have been ended. The statute, however, gives them the right, upon certain conditions, to *620have a new…

2Cases cited1 opinion

  1. Whiteley v. WhiteleyMichigan Supreme Court · 1896

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API