Maryland Casualty Co. v. Tindall

Not being able to concur in the views expressed in the majority opinion, I shall briefly state the grounds of my divergence therefrom.

There are two questions presented; first, is there_ a justiciable controversy presented, and second, is there any substantial evidence to sustain appellant’s contention relative thereto? Both of these questions are answered in the negative by the majority opinion. As set out in that opinion, appellant, which was plaintiff below, alleges that the cause of action set out in Tindall’s petition in the suit pending in the state court “is predicated upon the…