Bair v. Bair

(concurring):.As a general proposition, a collateral attack upon a judgment can be permitted only in cases where the judgment is invalid on jurisdictional grounds or where it was obtained through extrinsic fraud. Moycs v. Moyes, 60 Idaho 601, 94 P.2d 782 (1939) ; Rogers v. National Surety Co., 53 Idaho 128, 22 P.2d 141 (1933); Welch v. Morris, 49 Idaho 781, 291 P. 1048 (1930) ; Harkness v. Utah Power & Light Co., 49 Idaho 756, 291 P. 1051 (1930) ; Weil v. Defenbach, 36 Idaho 37, 208 P. 1025 (1922) ; O’Neill v. Potvin, 13 Idaho 721, 93 P. 20, 257 (1907).

I do not regard the decision in Treece…