Legal Opinion · Dissent

State v. Sosa

Utah Supreme Court

Decided July 5, 1979No. 15929Published

1DissentMaughan, Justice

In my view, the main opinion nullifies the plainly expressed intent of the legislature in Sec. 76-1^102(2) of our new penal code; misinterprets Sec. 77-16-1; and glides too easily over Article VIII, Sec. 7, Constitution of Utah. For those reasons, and the more extensive discussion of them in my dissent in State v. Cooley, Utah, 575 P.2d 693, 694-696 (1978), I dissent. Statutory references are to U.C.A.1953.

STEWART, J., concurs in the views expressed in the dissenting opinion of MAU-GHAN, J.

2Cases cited1 opinion

  1. State v. CooleyUtah Supreme Court · 1978