Application of Paul W. Garbo

MARTIN, Judge.

This is an appeal from the decision of the Board of Appeals of the United States Patent Office sustaining the examiner’s rejection of the single claim of appellant’s application for a design patent.

The appealed claim is as follows:

“The ornamental design for a cinematic multiple-place trainer for automotive drivers as shown and described.”

The reference relied on is:

“Your Car Magazine, April, 1954, page 43, ‘Behind The Wheel Training.’ ”

The examiner described the claimed design as follows:

“The claimed design is for a driver training arrangement in a narrow enclosure such as a…