Nichols v. Chittenden

With great regret I am compelled to withhold my assent to either of the opinions announced by my associates. Entertaining as I do profound respect for their views, I should doubtless yield my convictions and assent to the reversal of *69the judgment did I not believe that I was bound by the decision of the supreme court, which as I read it logically concludes the question. As will be observed my brother Thomson concurs in my construction of the code provisions, supporting the position by strong and to my mind unanswerable arguments. I should doubtless simply accept his reasoning Avhich may not…