Plumbers & Steamfitters Union Local 598 v. Washington Public Power Supply System

(dissenting) — I respectfully dissent. The evidence presented (1) fails to establish that the restricted workers were engaged in unprotected labor activity; (2) WPPSS failed to abide by its own rules and procedures in imposing sanctions against the six workers; and (3) WPPSS acted as accuser, investigator, judge, jury and sentencer. This method of imposing its restrictions constituted an intentional and unjustifiable third party interference with valid contractual relations between Bechtel and the six workers.

WPPSS' security officer, Robert Manion, who was at the scene on November 17, 1982,…