Application of Harry Sponnoble

BALDWIN, Judge.

This is an appeal from the decision of the Board of Appeals,1 affirming the examiner’s rejection of the sole remaining claim in appellant’s application2 for “Mixing Yial Construction” as “unpatentable over” either Bujan3 or Lock-hart4 in view of Jensen5 and either parsons et al.6 or Umbdenstock7 under 35 U.S.C. § 103. Following the first decision by the Board of Appeals, appellant requested reconsideration, and the board rendered a second decision denying any error in the first and making no changes therein.

In the decision from which this appeal stems, the board made reference…