James v. Western Union Tel. Co.

Mr., Acting Justice Ramage

(concurring and dissenting) : I concur in the opinion of Mr. Justice Watts, but dissent from the opinion of Mr. Justice Cothran. I think the Circuit Court ought to be affirmed as to the verdict against Western Union Telegraph Company.

Mr. Justice Watts in that part of his opinion concurred in by Messrs. Justices Cothran, Marion, and Greene, says:

“I think that his Honor was in error in stating to the jury: T don’t see how you can possibly find a verdict for the plaintiff except against both defendants.’ I think on this, the appellant, J. T. Gray, should have a new…