Voices, Inc. v. Up-To-Date Mfg. Co.

BUFFINGTON, Circuit Judge.

In the court below the owner of patent No. 1,507,826, issued September 9, 1924, to Leo J. Grubman for a sound-producing device for dolls, and of patent No. 1,588,354, issued June 8, 1926, to the same patentee for sound-producing device, filed two bills against the Up-To-Date Manufacturing Company, Inc., for infringement thereof.

Grubman’s devices are aptly described in the opinion in the Second Circuit, where these patents were involved in Voices, Inc., v. Uneeda Doll Co. (C. C. A.) 32 F.(2d) 673, as follows: “The devices are installed in dolls for simulating the…